Dinner At The George At Hathersage
Published On Sunday 1 May 2022 by Sticky Beak
See Recent Dining Out Reviews | See All Recent Reviews
You can’t fail to be impressed by The George at Hathersage when you first clap eyes on it; the huge stone building commands your attention with its imposing beauty. It has its own car park too, but that’s a bit more ‘bijoux’ - especially if you have a larger vehicle, if you get my drift (not that you’d be able to drift in it!). Thankfully the jalopy isn’t massive so The Man manoeuvred into a vacant spot pretty easily.
Inside, The George has a beautifully spacious reception area that serves both the restaurant and the accommodation, with the bar area off to the left. Straightaway, one of the team came to ask how they could help us and when we said we were booked in the restaurant for a meal, swiftly confirmed the booking and then escorted us to our table. Top marks for customer service.
The George has a fantastic wine menu that offers a massive choice of grape juices; lagers and beers are changed regularly so they aren’t in print, but just ask one of the team – they don’t bite! Whilst we ordered our drinks, the lovely young lady told us about the two dishes that were unavailable that evening in case we fancied them and got disappointed. Another fab bit of customer service from this super-friendly team! We were also asked if we wanted water for the table and opted for ‘Chateau De Derwent’ (tap water/council pop) – I’ve got to say that it wasn’t my favourite tap water, it reminded of the stuff we got in Lincolnshire when I lived there. I much prefer Amber Valleys’ tipple, which is perhaps as well, seeing as we live there!
As soon as we sat down at our table a sense of calm washed over me, thanks to the calming colour palate used to decorate the space. Putty toned walls were hung with nature and rural pictures and the perfectly pitched lighting was a mixture of globe fittings in the centre and pendants above the tables at the edge of the space. Green banquette seating was down one long wall and allowed the maximum amount of diners to be accommodated without being squished in like Sardines, and the free standing wooden tables were paired with chairs upholstered in Morris-inspired fabric in green and salmon tones.
The first dish on the starters section is a homemade Scotch Egg (£7.95), so His Nibs didn’t bother to look at the other choices!! I was torn between the White Crabmeat Pâté (£8.25) and the Tartlet, eventually settling on the Tartlet (£7.25).
It wasn’t long before our starters were winging their way over to us and we tucked in hungrily. I honestly don’t think you would find a deeper sunset coloured, richer tasting egg yolk if you scoured the entire kingdom! The look of pure joy on The Man Bird’s face said it all as he took that first bite; he remarked on how crisp and crunchy the outer crumbed coating was and the Sausage meat and Black Pudding blanket that cosseted the egg itself was utterly divine. A peppery Rocket salad and punchy Honey Mustard Mayonnaise added some zip that cut nicely through the richness of the egg, bringing a lovely balance of tastes and textures to this starter.
I was presented with an individual puff pastry tartlet and colourful partner of mixed leaves and slices of Poached Pear. Roasted Fennel, Red Onion and Blueberry Chutney and Vegan Cheese were contained within the puff pastry, so I was expecting a rampant onslaught of flavour to hit my taste buds. In the event, whilst it was very nice, the result was actually very subtle; a bit too subtle for me if I’m being totally honest. I wanted the glorious bounce of anise from the Fennel, and I wanted there to be a hint of firmness to this herb, so I was a little crest-fallen when neither of my wants materialised. The chutney was nice; full of flavour and comfortingly soft on the tongue. Now, before anyone accuses me of being anti-vegan, I am going to firmly state that I’m not; what I am though is anti-unremarkable, and I’m afraid that this is what I thought of the Vegan cheese. It wasn’t that it was vegan cheese, it was the fact that it was so mild and (frankly) bland in flavour; surely there is a mature/extra mature vegan cheese out there, and if so, this would have been so much tastier.
As I say, this is my particular interpretation of this starter; others out there may well think it’s the proverbial bees’ knees. The warm , poached Pear was gently fragrant and still just-firm, adding some much needed crunch in my mouth, and the mixed leaf salad not only looked pretty, it tasted yummy too. That’s the beauty of everyone having different palates and tastes – as my Mummy says “it wouldn’t do if we all liked the same thing” – which isn’t to say I didn’t like it, I did; I just didn’t have the same love affair with it that His Nibs had had with his starter.
For mains we’d chosen Sage and Chorizo stuffed Pork fillet, wrapped in Parma Ham with sautéed Kale, mashed Potatoes and served with a creamy Sage and Chorizo sauce and crispy Bacon (£17.95) and slow-cooked Rump of Lamb in a North African Tagine, served with Rocket and a Quinoa and Pomegranate salad (£20.50).
Clearly I was having a numpty night because I’d thought that my Tagine would come served in an individual sized Tagine; it didn’t, it came in a (still lovely) cast iron pot. The Lamb was very much in evidence - Chef certainly doesn’t skimp on the meat portion he serves - and it was cooked to absolute juicy perfection, literally melting in my mouth. There was a warming mix of spices used in the sauce that complimented the Lamb’s earthiness and sweetness, and Peppers, Chickpeas, and sliced Black Olives made this a hearty, satisfying meal. For those not familiar with North African or Moroccan cooking this dish provides a good starting point from which to explore the flavours of this wonderful genre of cuisine. I asked for some bread with which to soak up the last of the sauce, and I really think that a flatbread (maybe Cumin seed studded?) would’ve been a nice touch –The George makes its own Pizzas so could easily do flatbreads to go with the Tagine; just an idea, Chef. Intensely sweet/sharp Pomegranate seeds and Quinoa added a nice shot of texture, along with the fresh intensity of Rocket.
His Nibs’ choice of Sage and Chorizo stuffed Pork fillet was bang on the money! The stuffing really was a work of art; at first you think it’s heavy on the Chorizo but then the Sage blooms on the palate, and the balance of flavours is total perfection. If not treated and cooked with respect, Pork can sometimes be on the dry side but Chef clearly knows his craft because the meat was mild, creamy and gorgeously moist. The Sage and Chorizo sauce was wickedly creamy with the same great kick that the stuffing had, so the two elements layered together superbly well. Verdant, young Kale had been skilfully sautéed to retain all of its beautiful flavour and a bit of bite, texture-wise. The Man Bird said that it was the glass-smooth mash that had caught his attention the most; crispy Bacon pieces formed part of this dish and the Potato had a hint of the Bacon to it – perhaps from the use of its juices in seasoning it? Anyhow, the whole dish had been a joy to eat according to His Nibs.
We’d also ordered a side of Braised Red Cabbage (£3.50) and this was a plentiful and flavoursome addition to our table. I did almost order an extra mixed salad (£3.50) but figured that I already had enough salad on my plate, and this turned out to be the right decision.
For pudding I chose The George’s homemade Spiced Apple Strudel with Vanilla Creme Anglaise (£7.50) and The Man opted to have a flourless Chocolate Brownie with homemade Strawberry sauce and Salted Caramel Ice cream (£7.50) which shook the life out of me; I would’ve bet my house on him choosing the Sticky Toffee Pudding with Butterscotch sauce and Vanilla Ice Cream!
I couldn’t tell you the last time I saw Apple Strudel on a menu, it’s one of those superb puddings that have gone out of fashion; thankfully Chef here appreciates its merits and has included it on his menu. Crisp, thin Filo pastry, dusted with icing sugar, housed a marvellously scented grated Apple and Sultana mix. This minx was thoroughly delicious and was paired perfectly with a simple, room-temperature Creme Anglaise (that’s custard to you and me!) whose warm vanilla note sang on the taste buds. A selection of fresh fruits (Blueberries, Strawberries and Raspberries) added the final flourish to this marvellous pudding – all hail the Strudel say I!!
Despite my scepticism at The Man Birds’ choice of dessert, I have to admit that it was a mighty fine one. This (flourless) Brownie was everything you would want in this morsel: a nice crisp crust and ridiculously gooey centre with a good wallop of Cocoa taste. Chef’s version is even more chocolatey than chocolatey and is Nirvana for cocoaphiles like His Nibs! Something so intense needs an equally confident flavour partner and the homemade Strawberry sauce stepped up to the plate with some serious swagger, laying down its concentrated taste as if clearing the pot at the World Poker Championships. In contrast to the warmth of the Brownie was the coolness of the gorgeous Salted Caramel Ice cream whose silkiness lingered in the mouth very pleasingly.
We finished off our meals with a couple of black coffees from the Roastery in Sheffield, taking our time to savour its rich aroma and flavour. Throughout the evening the staff members had all been incredibly attentive, making sure we were enjoying our food at each course and checking that we were ok for drinks. It had been a lovely evening and I’m happy to award Hot Wings to The George at Hathersage as I had been to do with its sister venue, The Maynard at Grindleford.
| A Celebration of Flavours - The Sunday Thali at Lasani, Southwell Covid and The Lockdowns (wouldn't that be a fab name for an alt-rock group? - just sayin') proved to be a pivotal time for many businesses and people; one of them Read The Article | |
| Autumn Comforts and Culinary Delights at The Peacock, Owler Bar I never mind when a good day gets made even better, and this was most definitely the case last week. Landing in our inbox was a lovely invitation to enjoy the Read The Article | |
| Stairway to Roast Heaven at Piccalilli Nottingham Another Sunday rolled around, and we all know what that means - time for one of the best meals: an iconic British Roast Dinner. Heading off for Nottingham city, The Man Bird was well prepped Read The Article | |
| Evening Delights at Scoozi Clevedon: From Burrata to Beef Short-Rib The Man's day job took us down to Bristol and we took the opportunity to go out for dinner with one of his colleagues and their husband. Having previously dined at Scoozi Read The Article | |
| Tapas Madrid Ashbourne Serves Up a Fiesta of Flavour Over the years, we've met many a lovely manager, and Mark is no exception. Having previously been at the Moon and Dog pub in Derby, and at another venue in Ashbourne, Mark Read The Article | |
| A Tasty Sunday Lunch at The Tavern at Tansley It had been a good while, i.e. several years, since we'd last visited The Tavern at Tansley but, with the weather being dodgy (to say the least!) a foray out into the wilds of the ‘Shire wasn’t Read The Article | |
| From Empty Cupboards to Thai Treasures - Our Feast at Mimi Kitchen, Eastwood It's no secret that I'm a bit lacking in the kitchen, and I've never tried to pretend otherwise. However, you would think that I'd at least be able to ensure that Read The Article | |
| Sunday Roasts and Country Charm at The Red Lion, Birchover Finally, the rain came! Like most things, this was a double-edged sword: on the one hand, the gardens certainly needed the water; on the other, it was impeding mine and The Read The Article | |
| Exploring the New A La Carte Menu at Hart's Hotel & Kitchen, Nottingham The recipe for success is a simple one: give the people what they want. Another factor is not being afraid to try something new, even though there are no guarantees Read The Article | |
| Trying Out The New Afternoon Tea At Fairways At Chevin Golf Club There are Afternoon Teas and then there are the ones served at Fairways at Chevin Golf Club in Duffield. It has been an absolute joy to savour each Afternoon Tea that we've Read The Article | |